CAs lose case against cost accountants

This discussion is constructive appraisal of Accountancy in India and Accountancy Bodies have on the business. The focus will be from point of view of public interest and other stakeholders. Members are expected to discuss from point of view of current legislation prevailing in India and also contrast with international practises. Discuss on MRAs and MOU between the accounting bodies.

This is a open forum. Please share your opinion in professional manner or else face moderation.
Forum rules

This discussion is constructive appraisal of Accountancy in India and Accountancy Bodies have on the business. The focus will be from point of view of public interest and other stakeholders. Members are expected to discuss from point of view of current legislation prevailing in India and also contrast with international practises.

This is a open forum. Please share your opinion in professional manner or else face moderation.

CAs lose case against cost accountants

Postby cmagururajan on Mon Apr 04, 2016 11:44 pm

http://www.bangaloremirror.com/bangalore/others/CAs-lose-case-against-cost-accountants/articleshow/51638403.cms

Chartered accountants of Karnataka under the Karnataka State Chartered Accountants Association have lost their case against the Karnataka State Cost Accountants Association in the high court. The CAs had a grouse against the state government allowing cost accountants to audit the account books of cooperative societies in the state. They had thus challenged an amendment to the Karnataka Cooperative Societies Act made in 2014, which allowed parity between chartered accountants and cost accountants.

The change in the Act was necessitated when the 97th Constitutional amendment came into force in 2011. The states were required to make new laws mandating that all cooperative societies maintain accounts and get them audited. Karnataka amended its cooperative societies law to conform with the Constitution.

The chartered accountants challenged this amendment in the HC. They alleged that the government succumbed to the "pressure of lobbying and political pressure," by the cost accountants' fraternity and when the law was amended, the definition of 'auditor' was enlarged to include cost accountants. Otherwise, only chartered accountants or a CA firm could audit accounts. They claimed that there was a vast difference between the two professions and even in the syllabus studied by these two.

The government, however, defended including cost accountants in the amendment arguing that the cooperative sector in Karnataka included sugar factories, spinning mills and industrial societies which required costing work to be done by cost accountants. The syllabus studied by the two professions were very similar and there was a shortage of professionals, requiring it to bring cost accountant firms under the meaning of 'auditor and auditing firms'.

The HC dismissed the petition of the chartered accountants saying that the amendment was made by law and the court could not interfere in it. It also pointed out that chartered accountants were not making a case that auditing of accounts of a cooperative society was their exclusive domain. Thus cost accountants are now on par with chartered accountants at least as far as auditing accounts of cooperative societies in Karnataka goes.



DIFFERENCE BETWEEN THE TWO
Acost accountant is one who does the cost audits of a company. Basically, it refers to the calculation of cost per unit of output, and ways and methods to minimise expenditure and maximise output. This system is more useful in manufacturing industries. A cost accounting degree is given by the Institute of Cost and Works Accountancy (ICWA). A chartered accountant is one who does the financial or main audit of a company or enterprise. Basic works include making accounts, computation of taxes to be paid, filing of income tax returns, statutory audit, tax audit and internal audit among others. A chartered accountant degree is given by the Institute of Chartered Accountants of India (ICAI)
"What lies behind us and what lies before us are tiny matters compared to what lies within us."
cmagururajan
 
Posts: 1065
Joined: Wed Aug 13, 2008 5:57 pm
Location: Mumbai
Gender: Male
Full Name: CMA C K Guruajan
Education: BSc , AICWA
Year of Membership or Passing: 2005
ICAI (CMA) Membership: ACMA
Karma: 13

Re: CAs lose case against cost accountants

Postby sudhakaricwai on Wed Apr 06, 2016 5:12 pm

" They alleged that the government succumbed to the "pressure of lobbying and political pressure," by the cost accountants' "

Atleast now CAs know the power CMAs :)
sudhakaricwai
 
Posts: 325
Joined: Mon Feb 23, 2009 10:36 am
Gender: Male
Country: India (in)
Full Name: sudhakar omkaram
Education: Mcom AICWA
Year of Membership or Passing: 2001
ICAI (CMA) Membership: ACMA
Karma: 5

Re: CAs lose case against cost accountants

Postby sudhakaricwai on Wed Apr 06, 2016 6:27 pm

also if you look at below link which says CAs to audit accounts of private schools-Delhi
http://www.icai.org/new_news.html?news=7098

I strongly feel cost audit of schools/Hospitals (which are not covered under Cos act) would make more sense than financial audit.

Not sure how Aravind K was convinced with financial audit of private schools , infact it should have been Cost Audit.
sudhakaricwai
 
Posts: 325
Joined: Mon Feb 23, 2009 10:36 am
Gender: Male
Country: India (in)
Full Name: sudhakar omkaram
Education: Mcom AICWA
Year of Membership or Passing: 2001
ICAI (CMA) Membership: ACMA
Karma: 5

Re: CAs lose case against cost accountants

Postby vvrsankar on Thu Apr 07, 2016 1:28 am

One more key point in whole discussion is "The syllabus studied by the two professions were very similar" , then we can do what CAs do.
CMA Ravi Sankar Vipparla
రవి శంకర్ విప్పర్ల
vvrsankar
 
Posts: 318
Joined: Sun Sep 27, 2009 9:46 pm
Location: JESREY CITY
Gender: Male
Country: United States (us)
Full Name: Ravi Sankar Vipparla
Education: MBA, FCMA, CMA (USA)
Year of Membership or Passing: 1997
Occupation: Service - in finance and accounting
ICAI (CMA) Membership: FCMA
Karma: 1

Re: CAs lose case against cost accountants

Postby cma28321 on Thu Apr 07, 2016 12:21 pm

it is now a matter of time before the governments of states and center along with common public at large realise the illogical professional exclusivity of CA profession and empower CMAs also to add value to the profession of audit/assurance and allied services.
cma28321
 
Posts: 1151
Joined: Thu May 27, 2010 11:08 am
Location: Visakhapatnam, Andhra Pradesh
Gender: Male
Country: India (in)
Full Name: C V L N S SUBRAMANYAM
Education: B Com ACMA
Year of Membership or Passing: dec 2004
ICAI (CMA) Membership: ACMA
Karma: 11


Return to Accountancy Profession in India


Who is online

Users browsing this forum: No registered users and 1 guest